Bakery · Tinsley, Rotherham
Highgate Bakery Menu & Prices
Planning what to order at Highgate Bakery? This menu gathers the bakes you are most likely to find at a bakery like this, with indicative prices for 2026.
Indicative menu. Items and prices are typical for this style of bakery and are not supplied by Highgate Bakery. Always ask staff about allergens.
Savouries & Pasties
- Cheese and onion pastyV £3.20 Mature Cheddar, sweet onion and potato in a peppery shortcrust parcel.
- Steak bakePopular £2.60 Tender chunks of beef in rich peppery gravy, encased in layers of crisp puff pastry.
- Minced beef and onion pie £3.45 Seasoned minced beef and onion in proper gravy beneath a shortcrust lid.
- Sausage rollPopular £1.85 Seasoned pork sausage meat wrapped in golden, flaky puff pastry and glazed with egg.
- Vegetable pastyV £3.40 Carrot, peas, potato and swede, lightly spiced and baked in crimped shortcrust.
- Sausage, bean and cheese melt £2.10 Sausage, baked beans and melted cheese tucked into a golden puff pastry slice.
- Steak and kidney pie £4.45 Slow-cooked beef and kidney in thick gravy under a short, buttery pastry lid.
Breads & Rolls
- Crusty cobVVG £2.05 Round, crusty white cob with a satisfying crackle and a light, airy middle.
- Farmhouse whiteVVG £2.95 Deep, floured white loaf with a soft crumb that makes excellent toast.
- Soft white rolls (pack of 6)V £2.05 Pillowy white baps, perfect for bacon butties and packed lunches.
- White bloomerPopularVVG £3.45 Crusty, slashed white loaf with a soft, open crumb, baked fresh every morning.
- Split tinVVG £3.00 Classic white tin loaf with a distinctive split top and golden crust.
- Wholemeal tin loafPopularVVG £2.00 Wholesome stoneground wholemeal bread baked in a tin for easy, even slicing.
- Seeded batch loafVVG £2.95 Soft batch-baked loaf studded with sunflower, linseed and pumpkin seeds.
Sandwiches & Filled Rolls
- Tuna mayo and cucumber baguette £4.10 Flaked tuna in mayonnaise with crunchy cucumber in a fresh white baguette.
- Cheese and pickle sandwichV £2.60 Mature Cheddar and tangy brown pickle layered on farmhouse white.
- BLT sandwich £3.80 Smoky back bacon, crunchy lettuce and ripe tomato on lightly buttered bread.
- Hot bacon rollPopular £2.90 Grilled back bacon in a soft floured bap, served warm with your choice of sauce.
- Chicken salad baguette £3.85 Roast chicken, crisp leaves and tomato with a touch of mayonnaise.
- Coronation chicken sandwich £3.65 Chicken in a mild, fruity curried mayonnaise on soft white bread.
Cream Cakes & Buns
- Iced finger bunPopularV £1.35 Soft, sweet finger roll topped with a thick layer of white or pink icing.
- Jam doughnutV £0.90 Classic ring-free doughnut rolled in sugar with a raspberry jam centre.
- Belgian bunV £1.55 Sweet sultana swirl topped with white icing and a bright glacé cherry.
- Vanilla custard sliceV £2.55 Thick set vanilla custard between puff pastry layers with feathered white icing.
- Chocolate eclairV £2.20 Choux finger filled with fresh whipped cream and dipped in chocolate icing.
- Fresh cream doughnutPopularV £1.65 Sugared yeast doughnut split and filled with whipped cream and strawberry jam.
Traybakes, Tarts & Biscuits
- Eccles cakeV £1.50 Flaky pastry round packed with buttery spiced currants and sprinkled with sugar.
- Rocky roadV £2.95 Chocolate, crushed biscuit, marshmallow and cherries set into a chunky square.
- Bakewell tartVN £2.15 Shortcrust tart with raspberry jam, almond frangipane and a cherry on white icing.
- Gingerbread manV £1.50 Crisp, warmly spiced gingerbread figure with iced buttons and a smile.
- Golden syrup flapjackPopularV £1.85 Chewy oat bar baked with butter and golden syrup until caramelised at the edges.
- Fruit sconeV £2.15 Light, buttery scone dotted with sultanas, lovely with jam and clotted cream.
- Millionaire's shortbreadPopularV £2.00 Buttery shortbread base, thick caramel and a snap of milk chocolate on top.
- Viennese whirlV £1.95 Melt-in-the-mouth piped biscuits sandwiched with buttercream and raspberry jam.
Ordering tips for Highgate Bakery
- Arrive early for the widest choice – bread and the most popular bakes often sell out by lunchtime.
- Allergen information must be available on request under UK law – ask before you buy if you have an allergy.
Make a morning of it
All in RotherhamOther bakeries near Highgate Bakery
Bakery
Batch'd
Kiosk 2B The Arcade Meadowhall Centre, Meadowhall Way, Sheffield S9 1EP
Hours not listedHygiene 4/50.7 mi